My family lived in Donetsk, Ukraine for a spell when I was a young. There are so many things from our time there that I remember so vividly, and borscht is among the top.
Borscht in Ukraine is like chicken noodle soup in America. We ate it multiple times each week, and though every person has their own recipe it was always clear we were eating borscht. My version is AIP-friendly (auto-immune paleo), and the addition of the short ribs is definitely a liberty I've taken (not likely to see it in many homes in Ukraine). But beef bones and stock are classic to the dish, so it works amazingly well.
This version is AIP-friendly (auto-immune paleo), and the addition of the short ribs is definitely a liberty I've taken (not likely to see it in many homes in Ukraine). But beef bones and stock are classic to the dish, so it works amazingly well.
Prep Time15 minutesmins
Cook Time4 hourshrs
Course: Soup
Cuisine: Russian, Ukrainian
Keyword: borscht
Equipment
Cutting Board
Shun 8in Chef's Knife
6 qt Enameled Cast Iron Dutch Oven
9in Tongs
Ingredients
For braising the short ribs
8beef short ribssilver skin trimmed off
2tbspsalt
1 1/2tbsponion powder
2tbspgarlic powder
2-3tbspolive oil
2qtsbeef bone broth
2sprigsoregano
2sprigsthyme
For the soup
1applepeeled, cored, diced
2largebeetspeeled, diced
1/4headmedium cabbagechopped
1largeparsnipdiced
2mediumcarrotsdiced
4cupswater
TTsalt
To finish
2tbspred wine vinegar
coconut creamor sour cream if you aren't dairy free
fresh dillchopped
Instructions
Braise the short ribs
Preheat oven to 325. Toss the short ribs with the salt, onion powder and garlic powder. Put a large cast iron dutch oven (one that has a lid) on medium heat on the stove, and add the olive oil. Sear the short ribs on all sides.
Add the bone broth and herbs to the ribs, cover and place in the oven for 3 hours.
Make the soup
Remove the short ribs from the braising liquid and add the apple, beets, cabbage, parsnip, carrots, water, and a couple pinches of salt. Stir to combine and add the short ribs back on top. Cover and put in the oven for another 45-60 minutes, until the vegetables and short ribs are tender. Be sure to scrape the fond from the sides and add it back into the soup. Lots of flavor there.
Serve the soup
Put one short rib into each bowl. Stir the vinegar into the soup, then ladle the soup into each bowl with the short rib. Add the coconut cream (or regular cream if you prefer) and fresh dill. Serve while still steaming.
One of the best borscht recipes I've tried. I just used water rather than bone stock and it worked fine. I thought it might being a seasoned Irish stew maker. Thank you for this lovely addition to my repertoire.
I made this yesterday when it was miserably cold and rainy in Austin and heating up the house with the oven on all day sounded perfect. I couldn't find parsnips, so I just used a big white turnip and also added a peeled & diced Yukon Gold potato. The flavor was excellent and it was very filling, but it was also really fatty, which I didn't like. I think next time, I'll either halve the amount of short ribs and trim off the visible fat, or just use bones and/or half the amount of stew meat instead.
I made this in two parts, making the spare ribs the day before, and finishing the soup the next day. I riffed the recipe a bit, using a mix of beef and veggie broth, equal amounts parsnip and carrot, and a couple smaller yellow beets. A great use of all my CSA veggies! The balance of flavors was phenomenal, sweet and sour and rich in all the right ways!
Hi Chris - I am Ukrainian and look forward to trying this Borscht variation. Even my own family (grandparents, aunts, cousins and my Mother) made their own variations of the original recipes from my great grandmothers (different parts of Ukraine). All are delicious in their own way. Just like the many variations of pyrohy (potato dumpling, though I prefer saurkraut), holubchi (cabbage rolls, my Dad makes a seafood version to die for), paska (Easter bread, my Mom's is better than my grandmother's), etc. Will definitely try with the apple! Thank you!
Interesting adaptation but Borscht this is not. It’s missing some key ingredients which create a specific taste profile for this soup and still AIP. It’s like making marinara sauce but only using tomato and salt yet still calling it marinara. Ukrainians would laugh you out of the country for making this in the oven along with an apple. Maybe just braised beef with root veggies for the name.
I don't think that's true. I remember visiting the home of an elderly woman about a 45 minute train ride outside Donetsk and she used apple in her borscht. Is she less Ukrainian for it? Hardly. Every person who makes borscht has their take on it, and there's a lot of room for variation without condescension. I invite you to open your mind a little - you may be surprised how much you enjoy things that are different from how you think it should be done.
As a born and raised Ukrainian, we hold our family recipes dear to our hearts. Flavor profiles are everything in any dish. Aside from the apple (verified by my father, mother, and grandmother, and a few other friends) not an ingredient in Borscht. Sorry to disappoint. You were missing a few more very specific spices and produce. The story of the old lady is sweet. I’m sure you have many memories when you were in Ukraine. She may have given you a left curve ball with the apple ???? as I’ve said, we hold family recipes dear to our hearts.
My husband is lactose intolerant. What's your view of soy sour cream like Tofutti? I've used that in recipes that require dairy. Never tried using coconut cream in dishes that aren't SE Asian.
As a Russian, we eat borscht all the time but wow I’ve never had it with an apple and parsnips AND it being baked in the oven! Definitely need to try this new spin on the soup???? Chris is right, everyone makes it so different! It’s yummy with kidney beans too ☺️
Thanks for mentioning that! I'm afraid I didn't know that either & when I Googled it after reading your comment, I found several articles that explain why leaving the "the" out was important. In 1991, Ukraine gained independence from USSR & dropped the "the" that was previously used with the name. Using the pre-independence "the" with Ukraine is incorrect & possibly hurtful. Thanks for the kind heads-up, Serhiy!
"The" Ukraine was always a Russian thing, not a Ukrainian one. It was their way of emphasizing that Ukraine was not an actual nation, but a region of Russia. Which, of course, it is most certainly not.
Our family loves borscht. I make it every Christmas Eve. The red, green and white bowl is always so cheerful to tuck into after a busy afternoon and evening at church.
Your version here in interesting! I love the addition of cabbage and apple.
It's so good! I learned about the apple from a woman whose home we visited outside Donetsk. It was my favorite version I had, and I've always added it since.
Looking for our favorite things? A place to shop our home room by room, or just catch up on what Julia's wearing / loving right now? Browse the CLJ shop
Every year when I pack up the decorations after Christmas, I collect all of the garlands together in one box, I get all the candlesticks together in another box, and all my nativity sets go into their own box. We label the boxes "garlands," "candles," "nativity sets,"...which seems great until you remember that you have […]
What do you make for Christmas dinner? Sometimes we'll do a prime rib or a roast turkey, but this year, I'm going all out with a Christmas ham that just looks festive. For this recipe, I made a cranberry-orange glaze with some warm winter spices that takes this ham to the next level. Oh and […]
Raise your hand if you panic when your phone's low battery notification turns on? (Just me??) There's nothing worse when I'm out on a fun holiday outing taking video memories of my family, and I see that red light. Or I'm traveling and stuck in the airport on a layover...it gives me anxiety! I've tried […]
I put out a call on Insta to see if anyone needed help with holiday hosting, and I had so many great replies. There were some questions that popped up multiple times too, so I compiled this Q&A to hopefully help you prep for a smooth and stress-free hosting season. It can feel intimidating to […]
Another way for us to stay in touch! Joining our weekly newsletter gives you access to exclusive content, never-before-seen photos, your questions answered, and our favorite DIYs. Sign up below!
Welcome to our online community where we've posted home, DIY, style, renovations, and family since '09. Renovating our #cljmoderncottage in Idaho and headed for new adventures in Raleigh, NC. #cljfam #cljtransformations
One of the best borscht recipes I've tried. I just used water rather than bone stock and it worked fine. I thought it might being a seasoned Irish stew maker. Thank you for this lovely addition to my repertoire.
Coming back to print the recipe 'cause HOLY CRAP this was amazing.
So glad you liked it!
I made this yesterday when it was miserably cold and rainy in Austin and heating up the house with the oven on all day sounded perfect. I couldn't find parsnips, so I just used a big white turnip and also added a peeled & diced Yukon Gold potato. The flavor was excellent and it was very filling, but it was also really fatty, which I didn't like. I think next time, I'll either halve the amount of short ribs and trim off the visible fat, or just use bones and/or half the amount of stew meat instead.
This was so good!
I made this in two parts, making the spare ribs the day before, and finishing the soup the next day. I riffed the recipe a bit, using a mix of beef and veggie broth, equal amounts parsnip and carrot, and a couple smaller yellow beets. A great use of all my CSA veggies! The balance of flavors was phenomenal, sweet and sour and rich in all the right ways!
Hi Chris - I am Ukrainian and look forward to trying this Borscht variation. Even my own family (grandparents, aunts, cousins and my Mother) made their own variations of the original recipes from my great grandmothers (different parts of Ukraine). All are delicious in their own way. Just like the many variations of pyrohy (potato dumpling, though I prefer saurkraut), holubchi (cabbage rolls, my Dad makes a seafood version to die for), paska (Easter bread, my Mom's is better than my grandmother's), etc. Will definitely try with the apple! Thank you!
Interesting adaptation but Borscht this is not. It’s missing some key ingredients which create a specific taste profile for this soup and still AIP. It’s like making marinara sauce but only using tomato and salt yet still calling it marinara. Ukrainians would laugh you out of the country for making this in the oven along with an apple. Maybe just braised beef with root veggies for the name.
I don't think that's true. I remember visiting the home of an elderly woman about a 45 minute train ride outside Donetsk and she used apple in her borscht. Is she less Ukrainian for it? Hardly. Every person who makes borscht has their take on it, and there's a lot of room for variation without condescension. I invite you to open your mind a little - you may be surprised how much you enjoy things that are different from how you think it should be done.
As a born and raised Ukrainian, we hold our family recipes dear to our hearts. Flavor profiles are everything in any dish. Aside from the apple (verified by my father, mother, and grandmother, and a few other friends) not an ingredient in Borscht. Sorry to disappoint. You were missing a few more very specific spices and produce. The story of the old lady is sweet. I’m sure you have many memories when you were in Ukraine. She may have given you a left curve ball with the apple ???? as I’ve said, we hold family recipes dear to our hearts.
My husband is lactose intolerant. What's your view of soy sour cream like Tofutti? I've used that in recipes that require dairy. Never tried using coconut cream in dishes that aren't SE Asian.
I've never tried it but I'm sure it would be great!
As a Russian, we eat borscht all the time but wow I’ve never had it with an apple and parsnips AND it being baked in the oven! Definitely need to try this new spin on the soup???? Chris is right, everyone makes it so different! It’s yummy with kidney beans too ☺️
I've never seen it with kidney beans! That sounds like a great thing to add.
Not in _The_ Ukraine, just Ukraine
Thanks for mentioning that! I'm afraid I didn't know that either & when I Googled it after reading your comment, I found several articles that explain why leaving the "the" out was important. In 1991, Ukraine gained independence from USSR & dropped the "the" that was previously used with the name. Using the pre-independence "the" with Ukraine is incorrect & possibly hurtful. Thanks for the kind heads-up, Serhiy!
"The" Ukraine was always a Russian thing, not a Ukrainian one. It was their way of emphasizing that Ukraine was not an actual nation, but a region of Russia. Which, of course, it is most certainly not.
You're right! Apologies, it's updated.
Our family loves borscht. I make it every Christmas Eve. The red, green and white bowl is always so cheerful to tuck into after a busy afternoon and evening at church.
Your version here in interesting! I love the addition of cabbage and apple.
It's so good! I learned about the apple from a woman whose home we visited outside Donetsk. It was my favorite version I had, and I've always added it since.