Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

Product Tests

The Ultimate Test: The Best Waterproof Mats

September 18, 2024

This post is not sponsored and all opinions are my own.

If there are rainy seasons in North Carolina, it's usually the summer and winter. Summer is drenching thunderstorms and winter is just a steady drizzle on and off every other week. A coir, fabric or jute doormat is great if you want to show off some personality in the drier months. However, you need something more weather-resistant for people (and pets) to step on inside or out this time of year, especially with wet, dirty shoes or paws.

Chris Loves Julia | Julia walking through her front door onto a waterproof mat

Argyle Door Mat Runner

An interior waterproof doormat is just a functional, practical, necessary piece of decor to protect the floors this time of year. Sure you can have it be a color that matches your room, but I just like it to match the floor. To me it’s not a design element, I just want it to blend in.

But the most essential part is that it does its job: it needs to handle the water, not slip around, and dry quickly for a potential part two the next day. Because when it rains, it often pours! So I wanted to check out what's on the market right now to help you (and me!) find the best weatherproof indoor/outdoor doormats.

In case you love product tests as much as I do, check out the ones we've done on steam mops, nugget ice makersknife sharpenerscan openers, and hair towel wraps!

The Test Methodology

Chris Loves Julia | Pouring water onto a waterproof mat

We measured the size, calculating the surface area available, and weighed 10 rubber-backed door mats right out of the box. Then we poured increments of 1 cup of water onto them until we saw water visibly seeping out the sides. Using 8 oz/cup, we calculated the weight of water they could each handle. Then we left the mats to air dry in our office overnight and weighed them each again 24 hours later to see what percentage of water had evaporated. We also shuffled across the mats to see how slippery they were when wet.

Chris Loves Julia | A waterproof mat seeping out water

The Results

In order of price (from least to most expensive):

Target Apache Mills Diamond Tufted Door Mat

Target Apache Mills Diamond Tufted Door Mat - $9.99

Weight out of the box: 4.8 pounds
Size: 29.625" x 17.625"
Surface area: 522.14" ($0.02/square inch)
Backing: Slightly "smooth"/slightly textured rubber with no grippers
Slipperiness: Decently grippy on top when wet
Absorption breaking point: Not even 3 cups—it started crying a river to the sides
How much water evaporated after 24 hours: 23.8%
Size/color options: 1 size/1 color
Overall impressions: This was a disappointment...it couldn't even handle our "minimum" water test. The water didn't evaporate very quickly either. It claims to feature recycled polyester fibers on the facing and 100% recycled rubber backing. This is the cheapest mat at $0.02/square inch...and it feels like it.

Amazon HIYARD Mat

Amazon HIYARD Mat - From $14.99

Weight out of the box: 2.4 pounds
Size: 29" x 17"
Surface area: 493" ($0.03/square inch)
Backing: Large-size diamond grid grip pattern
Slipperiness: Decently grippy when wet
Absorption breaking point: 3 cups
How much water evaporated after 24 hours: 35.1%
Size/color options: 2 sizes/5 colors
Overall impressions: This one had the most reactions from the team: "She’s flooded! She's a goner..." It looked cheap, like a grid of chair felt pads added to the top of a flat material. The water really pooled up on top and didn't absorb very well, but it did dry relatively more quickly than some.

Amazon GOYLSER Entry Mat

Amazon GOYLSER Entry Mat - From $19.99

Weight out of the box: 2.4 pounds
Size: 33.25" x 21.25"
Surface area: 706.6" ($0.03/square inch)
Backing: Textured smooth rubber with fabric hem
Slipperiness: Sloshy water sound but decently grippy
Absorption breaking point: 3 cups
How much water evaporated after 24 hours: 33.3%
Size/color options: 7 sizes/6 colors (not all sizes have all colors available)
Overall impressions: I like the stripe on this one—it's a little bit more aesthetic if you do want a mat that commands some attention. It did feel flimsy compared to the other mats, and it didn't lay totally flat out of the box—there were creases visible. It wasn't as slippery as I was worried it would be, though, and the range of color options is nice.

Amazon Color&Geometry Door Mat

Amazon Color&Geometry Door Mat - From $22.99

Weight out of the box: 1.6 pounds
Size: 29.25" x 17.125"
Surface area: 500.9" ($0.05/square inch)
Backing: Textured smooth rubber with fabric hem Slipperiness: Decently grippy when wet
Absorption breaking point: 3 cups
How much water evaporated after 24 hours: 48.39%
Size/color options: 7 sizes/4 colors
Overall impressions: Argh, it won't lay flat right out of the box! And it feels a little flimsy. The water test produced almost a slick sheet of water on top that didn't absorb right away. "She's going overboard, folks!" But then ironically this mat actually looked kind of nice when wet? It flattened out more. It did dry pretty quickly: the next day it felt minimally wet and was back to its starting weight.

Gorilla Grip Ultra Absorbent Moisture Guard Doormat

Gorilla Grip Ultra Absorbent Moisture Guard Doormat - From $31.99

Weight out of the box: 2.6 pounds
Size: 29" x 17"
Surface area: 493" ($0.06/square inch)
Backing: Large-size diamond grid grip pattern
Slipperiness: Slightly slippery
Absorption breaking point: 3 cups
How much water evaporated after 24 hours: 33.3%
Size/color options: 6 sizes/7 colors
Overall impressions: This mat was actually a little slippery when wet, and really wasn't living up to its name. I just was a little let down by this one—I had higher hopes.

L.L. Bean Everyspace Recycled Waterhog Doormat

L.L. Bean Everyspace Recycled Waterhog Doormat - $34.95

Weight out of the box: 2 pounds
Size: 26.875" x 18"
Surface area: 483.75" ($0.07/square inch)
Backing: Medium-sized diamond grid grip pattern
Slipperiness: A little slippery on top when wet
Absorption breaking point: 3 cups and then it started to spill over the sides a little
How much water evaporated after 24 hours: 25.7%
Size/color options: 4 sizes/8 colors
Overall impressions: Nice light mat with a handsome diamond pattern on the front and a good sense of "grippiness" on the back so it won't slide around. It did get a little bit slippery on top when wet. This one uses 90% recycled polyester on the rug.

Crate & Barrel Thirsty Dots ™ Flax Doormat

Crate & Barrel Thirsty Dots ™ Flax Doormat - $45

Weight out of the box: 4 pounds
Size: 34.875" x 22.875"
Surface area: 797.8" ($0.06/square inch)
Backing: Medium-sized diamond grid grip pattern
Slipperiness: A little bit slippery on top when fully wet
Absorption breaking point:: 5 cups
How much water evaporated after 24 hours: 35.3%
Size/color options: 3 sizes/3 colors
Overall impressions: The front dots on this one were pretty tall, so you don't really slosh in the water if it is drenched. It didn't absorb quite as much as those in its "weight class" if you will, and it was a little bit slippery. It does feature 100% post-consumer recycled plastic on the rug and 20% recycled rubber on the back.

Orvis Grid Recycled Water Trapper® Mat

Orvis Grid Recycled Water Trapper® Mat - From $45

Weight out of the box: 4.2 pounds
Size: 34.875" x 23"
Surface area: 802" ($0.06/square inch)
Backing: Medium-sized diamond grid grip pattern
Slipperiness: Decently grippy on top when wet
Absorption breaking point: 6 cups
How much water evaporated after 24 hours: 33.3%
Size/color options: 7 sizes/8 colors
Overall impressions: The Orvis, Pottery Barn, L.L.Bean, Crate & Barrel, and Frontgate mats all had what seemed like the exact same rubber grip backing; They really only differed on the front pattern, sizes, and color options. And Orvis really impressed on the options at an accessible price point. I also liked that it used 100% recycled materials in the rug fibers and 20% recycled rubber in the backing.

Pottery Barn Waterhog Squares Monogram Doormat

Pottery Barn Waterhog Squares Monogram Doormat - $59

Weight out of the box: 4 pounds
Size: 35.5" x 23"
Surface area: 816.5" ($0.07/square inch)
Backing: Medium-sized diamond grid grip pattern
Slipperiness: Decently grippy on top when wet
Absorption breaking point: 6 cups
How much water evaporated after 24 hours: 28.6%
Size/color options: 1 size/7 colors
Overall impressions: Loving the monogram that you can order with this one! Really makes it personalized. The size was great for a front door, and it looks more sophisticated than many utility mats. This one uses 100% recycled materials in the rug fibers and 25% recycled rubber backing. I'm eyeing this one for the mudroom entry!

Frontgate Water & Dirt Shield™ Argyle Door Mat

Frontgate Water & Dirt Shield™ Argyle Door Mat - From $59

Weight out of the box: 6.2 pounds
Size: 58.875" x 22"
Surface area: 1295.25" ($0.09/square inch)
Backing: Medium-sized diamond grid grip pattern
Slipperiness: Really grippy when wet
Absorption breaking point: 11 cups (not a typo...it was wild to watch)
How much water evaporated after 24 hours: 38.46%
Size/color options: 2 sizes/8 colors
Overall impressions: We tested the larger size ($119), and it is quite a substantial mat in terms of weight and size, so if you have double doors to your front or back entrance, this is your mat. It handled so much water without breaking a "sweat," and was the most secure-feeling in terms of slipperiness when wet. Feels like it will last a long time! I think this is going right inside my front door this season.

The Top 3

Our top picks all performed really well, felt sturdy underfoot, and absorbed more water than average. It was evident that you get what you pay for—most of the lowest-performing mats were under $20. So if you need something to stand up to the rain and dirt, definitely consider one of these for inside or outside your door!

Best Waterproof Door Mat for Performance: Frontgate Water & Dirt Shield™ Argyle Door Mat

Best Waterproof Door Mat for Style: Pottery Barn Waterhog Squares Monogram Doormat

Best Waterproof Door Mat for Size/Color Options: Orvis Grid Recycled Water Trapper® Mat

— Hide Comments
+ ShowComments
What do you think?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  1. Thank you for this! I’m going for the Frontgate option. Is the color displayed in the photo above camel or dark brown?

  2. Thank you for all the hard work you did for testing mat materials and performance. I’ll go ahead and order a few.
    Tracy

  3. Helpful! I have an uncovered stoop and would like an outdoor mat for scrubbing off dirt that won't hold liquid. These all seem like better for inside the door, is that your impression?

    1. Some of these have descriptions that they are for indoor *or* outdoor use, though they'll wear faster outside of course.

  4. My utility room has an LL Bean mat (but will now have to check out some others …) but by the front door (less traffic), I have an LL Bean mat with an Annie Selke rug on top of it. Cute color with absorption under!

  5. Great roundup. I am looking for a mat I can mutilate - I want to cut out a rectangle the size of a floor vent and use it next to a sliding door that has a floor vent right in front of it. And something scrubbable, because the dog is the guiltiest party for getting that part of the floor wet. Will check these out.

    1. We went with the camel, but you can't go wrong with either! I like mine to almost match the floor color.

  6. I purchased a Gorilla Grip mat in April 2023 and I use it outside. The tufted top is fraying. I expected it to wear better and longer.

What We're

Loving

Right Now

What We're

Loving

Right Now

Looking for our favorite things? A place to shop our home room by room, or just catch up on what Julia's wearing / loving right now? Browse the CLJ shop
Shop All

Love Stories

Love Where You Live

In an industry that often feels designed to make you discontent, we want this to be place you come for inspiration, ideas, and encouragement to make the space you're already in feel like home.
Read All Posts
let's break this thing up

BROWSE BY CATEGORY

01

Portfolio

Befores, afters, mood boards, plans, failures, wins. We’ve done a lot of projects, and they’re all here.
read more
02

Projects

We have a long-standing relationship with DIY, and love rolling our sleeves up and making it happen.
read more
03

Design

Even when you don’t want to rip down a wall, you can make that space in your home better. Right now.
read more
hello world!

looking for inspiration?

Best Of

The Best Of September 2024

Can you believe that September has already come and gone? This time of year is my absolute favorite and we've been busy finishing up house projects (the mudroom is officially checked off the 2024 project list!) and launching two new product lines! It was such a surreal moment to see our wallpaper designs on the shelves at Lowes […]
Entertaining

12 Tips for How to Host and Make Your Guests Feel Completely at Ease

I recently got a question from a commenter who asked me how I entertain at home to make guests feel at ease. This question came at a great time since fall can be a natural hosting season from watch parties (there's football...or The Bach) to Thanksgiving. The truth is — Chris and I really *enjoy* […]
North Carolina Home

Our Exterior House Tour | Fall 2024

This year has been the (slightly unexpected) year of our exterior renovation! And, honestly, the house has never felt more us. All the renovations we've done to our "Modern Colonial" North Carolina home feel like they represent the elements that I loved so much about our last house in Idaho. There's this moody exterior with […]
Chris Cooks

Blackberry Campfire S’mores

I'm even more excited to share today's recipe with you because it's more than just a dessert—it inspired a lip balm flavor! That's right, we just launched a collaboration with our friends at Poppy & Pout based on three fall desserts that I developed just for you. We love Poppy & Pout because they're just […]
Learn With Us
Want to do what we do? Get the tools, mentorship, and training to be a Good Influencer professionally.
Learn More
Looking for Something?

SEARCH THE BLOG

We've been doing this since 2009 and we've posted a whopping 24145+ blog posts and counting. You might need a little help searching, huh?

Can We Send You Our Love Letter?

Another way for us to stay in touch! Joining our weekly newsletter gives you access to exclusive content, never-before-seen photos, your questions answered, and our favorite DIYs. Sign up below!

hello world!
Follow Along on Instagram
Welcome to our online community where we've posted home, DIY, style, renovations, and family since '09. Renovating our #cljmoderncottage in Idaho and headed for new adventures in Raleigh, NC. #cljfam #cljtransformations
© 2024 Chris Loves Julia, LLC
PRIVACY POLICYTERMS & CONDITIONSAFFILIATE DISCLAIMERSITE CREDITCOMMUNITY GUIDELINES