During all three of my pregnancies, I would drive to Sonic and purchase their perfectly-sized, crunchy ice—I just had to have it! Whether you prefer to call them pebble ice, nugget ice, or even the infamous “sonic ice,” there’s something so satisfying about those crunchy little ice pellets. In our quest to satisfy the insatiable craving for nugget ice, we embarked on a rigorous testing journey to uncover the best nugget ice maker.
We ordered some of the top-rated makers and set up shop in our team office kitchen. Over the course of weeks, we meticulously evaluated their performance, ice quality, user-friendliness, and overall satisfaction. Keep scrolling for the results!
Why We Tested the Best Countertop Nugget Ice Makers
You may remember from our viral beverage station that we incorporated a built-in nugget ice maker, which has been a complete luxury. I personally scoop ice from it about five times a day, but it gets constant use from our family of five. It’s perfect. It’s hooked up to plumbing, so we never have to refill the water or anything. We love a self-sufficient kitchen appliance! It’s also built-in and quite the investment, so for this test we wanted to focus on strictly countertop ice makers.
Without spoiling the results, I’ll say that there’s an ice maker out there for every personal preference and budget, and I would actually recommend a few of these for different reasons. Okay, let’s go!
2026 Comparison: The Top Pebble Ice Makers at a Glance
| Model | Output | Best For |
| GE Profile Opal (Magnolia) | 34 lbs/day | Best Overall & Aesthetics |
| WIBIMEN Mini Pebble Ice Trays | 0.5 lbs/day | Best Budget & Small Space |
| GE Opal 2.0 XL + Side Tank | 38 lbs/day | Best High-End / Tech Features |
Opal Nugget Ice Maker with Side Tank
We had this GE Opal countertop appliance for two years, actually. We bought it for the team office back in the day so our team could have icy cold beverages at their fingertips. This is “The Ice Maker” that everyone is getting these days. It’s considered the gold standard. Pictured is the 1.0 we tested a couple of years ago, but we had to get the upgraded version for comparison.
KBice 2.0 Self-Dispensing Nugget Ice Maker
I found this pebble ice maker quite attractive and knew we had to test out the dispensing feature to see if it is as convenient as it seems!
VivoHome Nugget Ice Maker
Unlike the Opal ice maker, this one has a self-cleaning feature, and it’s less than half the price, so I wanted to see how it compared.
GE Profile Opal Nugget Ice Maker – Hearth & Hand™ with Magnolia
We added this one to our test after enjoying the original GE Opal machine above and after seeing how sleek it looked. We opted out of buying the side tank (an additional $70), just to see if that made a difference against the other GE Opal model.
WIBIMEN Mini Pebble Ice Cube Trays
Not everyone has the space for a countertop nugget ice maker. We wanted to see if the low-priced pebble ice tray could have a seat at the table too!
Testing the Nugget Ice Makers
In order of price, low to high.
WIBIMEN Mini Pebble Ice Cube Trays $13.99
Dimensions: 8.78″L x 5.47″W x 2.05″H
Output volume: Makes approx 1/2 pound of ice per day
I didn’t have high expectations for these cute trays, and yet…they actually worked really well!
A couple of things to note: 1) Filling the trays is a little tricky. You have to pour very close to the tray in order to avoid it splashing back at you. 2) When you put the lid on top, expect some little geysers to pop up. That’s how you know you have enough water. 3) The ice itself? The perfect little spheres! They’re not too large, and actually so uniform that it soothes the eye. They seem to melt slower than the rougher-edged styles.
The downside is that it takes 6+ hours to make one batch, it’s a bit messy, and the quantity is low. Still, these are a great buy. Definitely get the 2-pack at least and consider the 4-pack if you’re more than a household of two people.
VivoHome Nugget Countertop Ice Maker $269
Dimensions: 13.2″D x 9.4″W x 15.3″H
Output volume: Makes 44 lb of ice per day
I would say that this ice maker is the budget version of the Opal ice maker. It’s smaller in size and has a really nice stainless steel finish. I also love that it has a flip-top lid for scooping out your ice. According to the product description, this one wins for holding the most amount of ice at 3.3 lbs!
As for the actual ice, it’s the perfect size to chew on, but it was a bit rougher around the edges than the others. And somehow, the ice is harder to chew, whereas the others made softer-crunch ice. Also, it seemed to melt faster than the others.
This one does have a self-clean feature, which is so convenient.
KBice 2.0 Self-Dispensing Nugget Ice Maker $299
Dimensions: 16″D x 12″W x 17.5″H
Output volume:: Makes 32 lb of ice per day
The black/stainless steel combo is lovely and has a really modern, simple shape. It’s also the largest, which is less than ideal if you’re short on counter space. That being said, the dispensing action on this machine is incredibly satisfying and easy to use.
You won’t ever have to dig out a scooper, and I would trust my kids with this machine because it’s so simple. Oh, and it fits a Stanley Cup perfectly without the bottom drip tray!
This isn’t considered a downside, but unlike the other ice makers, you can’t visually see how much ice has been made. And you can’t see the water level either. Actually, filling it with water is a bit odd at first, but also fun. You poke the funnel into the hole on the front side and pour the water in. And since you can’t see the fill line from the outside, the machine beeps at you when it’s full.
The ice pebbles are everything you want them to be–top-notch texture and perfectly crunchy. This one also has a self-cleaning feature.
GE Profile Opal Nugget Ice Maker – Hearth & Hand™ with Magnolia $349 on sale
Dimensions: 17.25″ (H) x 14.25″ (W) x 15.5″ (D)
Output volume: Makes 34 lbs of ice per day
In my opinion, this appliance is the prettiest of the bunch. This is one of the quietest of the bunch and the most aesthetic, thanks to the Hearth & Hand collaboration. It makes ice pretty quickly—from plugging in the machine to a full bucket was only about 2 hours. It holds 3 lb of ice.
The magnetic scoop holder that attaches to the side is a truly ingenious feature. In fact, it earns major points from our testing panel who don’t like it when the scoop is left in the ice or awkwardly on top of the machine. It’s the only one that has that feature!
The ice itself is pleasingly conical and crunchy, not melting too fast. When you pull out the handle to open the bucket of ice, it may seem a little wobbly, but don’t worry, you can pull it down all the way, and it will stay open for easy dispensing. You can order the matching side tank ($70) to refill it less often, but it’s not really necessary.
GE Profile Opal 2.0 XL Nugget Ice Maker with Side Tank $429
Dimensions: 17.5″D x 13.43″W x 16.5″H
Output volume: Makes 38 lbs of ice per day
This particular ice maker is expensive, but comes with some fancier options. This GE Opal has smart features that connect with your Alexa or Google Home device—not sure exactly how useful that would be in real life, but it does make “on-demand ice”. For this one, it comes with the side tank automatically, which is good for a crowd. There’s a self-clean button, and it also holds 3 lb of ice.
We had the previous model for years, and over time, it presented some minor issues (we ultimately had to retire it after 2 years), but this one seems to be an upgrade so far. Like the other Opal, it seems to make ice the quickest, and with the side tank, you won’t have to refill very often.
The Winners of the Nugget Ice Maker Test
Best Pebble Ice Maker Overall
GE Opal with Hearth & Hand: The GE Opal with Hearth & Hand is the sweet spot. You’re getting that high-quality, perfectly crunchy “Sonic ice” in a machine that actually looks like decor.
Best Budget Pebble Ice Maker
WIBIMEN Pebble Ice Cube Trays: Don’t sleep on these trays. If you’re a “weekend treat” person or have a tiny apartment, these are the $14 solution to your pebble ice dreams.
More Product Tests
Want more of our product tests? Check these out!
- Putting Kitchen Towels to the Test
- We Tested the Top 5 Amazon Pillows–Here’s My Favorite!
- Putting Bed Pillows to the Test
- Ranking the Top 7 Duvet Inserts on Amazon
- The Ultimate Cordless Stick Vacuum Test!
- We Tested Rug Pads–Here’s Our Favorite!
- We Tested 30 Hand Soaps to Find the Best of the Best
- Hunting for The Best Can Opener
- The Quest For the Best Hair Towel Wrap
- Unwrapping The Best: Putting Gift Wrap Cutters to The Test
- The Ultimate Test: Finding the Best Nugget Ice Maker
- We Tested Tons of Shaker Bottles For “Sexy Water”—Here Are the Winners
- Let’s Cut to the Chase: The Best Knife Sharpeners
- The Ultimate Test: The Best Waterproof Doormats
- Tried & Tested Dripless Tapered Candles
- Which Holiday Window Candles Are Right for You?
- The 9 Best Chef’s Knives
- Blender Wars! Testing And Ranking 7 Of The Best Blenders
- Product Test: Portable Phone Chargers
- The Ultimate Test: The Best Steam Mops
- We Tested 10 Solar Path Lights To Find The Perfect Glow
- Product Test: Mandoline Slicers (Did My Favorite One Hold Up?)
I bought the GE for the family a couple of years ago. Did the recommended prep before using it. Then literally within days the unit woke EVERYONE up with INSANE high-volume screeching at 2-3 am. Then I went down the rabbit hole of owners who did gobs of forensic research in hopes of fixing their GE nugget icemaker. There were sooooo many people online on countless threads trying to decipher this pricey nightmare. Same complaints… high-volume screeching, etc., then ‘fixes’ that involved 2-3x a month vinegar cleanings and only using distilled water, etc. Far too much effort for the output, in our opinion. For now, we will occasionally buy 10lb bags of nugget ice from Sonic when we’re having people over etc.
Post-mortem: We quickly returned this pricey dog to Amazon and got our money back.
Yikes, sounds like a lemon! We haven’t had that experience.
Are there any ice molds that make smaller pebble ice?
I purchased the Opal 2.0. Best ice maker for 27 months. GE warrants for 1 year so tough luck. I won’t buy again. Too expensive
I’ve had a GE Opal for 4 years. Have a major love-hate relationship with that thing. It has functioned well over time. No issues with the mechanics. It is loud when making ice and refilling the water storage unit can be a pain… as well as transferring the whole unit closer to the sink to give it a good deep cleaning. It’s heavy…. really heavy. All of these nit picky little inconveniences are just that…nit picky. I do love the ice. Majorly love the ice. Have I mentioned that? I do not… and this is a huge NOT… like that I am having one heckuva time cleaning out the whole system from mold/grime/black stuff in the ice. I turned off the unit for a few months. Don’t ask me why. I don’t remember. Could be that I had to clean the unit once again and was feeling lazy… months worth of no pellet ice, lazy. Well… I’ve bleached, vinegared, hot watered the system ad nauseam… and to my chagrin… the ice that comes out is completely disgusting. I’ve removed the back plate to see if I could internally access the water lines/milk them of what might be causing the ick… and still no luck. Now I’m contemplating chucking my Opal and buying another ice maker. If anyone has suggestions how to mitigate my ice maker issue, I”d be happy to hear your thoughts. GE Opal owners beware.
Great write up and comparison&J!! Many Thanks.
One component I wish I had been shared was motor noise. (Although maybe they’re all the same so it wasn’t a true variable!) We have the Opal and it is so dang loud when it’s making ice. It’s in our kitchen within range of our living room/TV watching area, and we have to turn the volume up on the TV when the Opal is making ice. :) Just a funny thing I wish I’d researched before buying.